How to take an evidence-based approach when answering drug and health information questions

Part of a comprehensive series on drug information literacy and critical evaluation. This article explores how to use a seven-step systematic approach to answer drug and health information questions.
Purple background with computer and screen, papers, book, pharmacy cross, white pills, black pen and darker purple magnifying glass

At the end of this article, you should be able to:

Health professionals frequently have medication or therapy related questions arise during practice. There may be the expectation of an immediate response, so clinicians often seek simple, short answers to their questions. This — coupled with the impression that informal questions do not require in-depth research and analysis, and a lack of training in locating medication information in a systematic manner — may lead clinicians to take a more casual approach to answering health-related questions. However, many simple questions turn out to have complex answers if an appropriate, thorough approach to finding relevant information is used. The process used to answer a medication- or health-related question should be the same regardless of the context in which the question arose or was received, the perceived simplicity of the question or need, or the individual asking the question. Using a structured, systematic and evidence-based approach is both necessary and possible even in busy practice scenarios. It ensures an accurate and thorough response is provided to all questions.

Evidence-based medicine refers to the use of current, best evidence in clinical decision-making, which requires the incorporation of the strongest external evidence with clinical expertise. Key components of evidence-based medicine include critical literature appraisal, clinical judgement, knowledge about the involved patient and the use of a sound scientific basis for decision-making when such evidence exists. The steps involved in the provision of evidence-based medicine include:

  • Forming specific clinical questions;
  • Searching for and retrieving the ‘best’ evidence;
  • Critically appraising the evidence for strength, validity, usefulness and importance;
  • Summarising and applying the results to clinical practice;
  • Evaluating performance and follow up for improvement.

Subsequently, the use of evidence-based medicine has evolved to other areas of practice, and a more inclusive term of evidence-based practice is often used interchangeably or to denote the use of evidence-based medicine principles for specific practice-related objectives. The PICO model is a method used in evidence-based practice to develop a clinical question or to help apply appropriate evidence to answering specific questions. The acronym PICO stands for:

  • Patient/population/problem;
  • Intervention;
  • Control/comparison;
  • Outcome.

While the term ‘evidence-based medicine’ is fairly contemporary, a systematic approach to answering drug information questions was first introduced in 1975 to aid in the training of students and pharmacists not adept at providing medication information​1​. Since the introduction of this systematic approach, several modifications have been made to elaborate on the initial concepts and to further elucidate needs when answering information requests​1,2​.

The number of steps involved in the different versions of the systematic approaches to answering questions usually ranges from seven to nine. Some versions combine similar concepts to produce fewer steps, while others separate out certain aspects into more steps. Regardless of the number of steps, all versions involve the same basic concepts that are analogous to the provision of evidence-based medicine in clinical practice.

This article focuses on the use of a seven-step systematic approach to answering medication-related questions and is used to ensure that these types of questions are handled consistently regardless of the clinician locating the information, the specific question/information need, or the context in which a question is asked. The specific steps described here for answering medication-related questions mimic those steps involved in the use of evidence-based medicine to resolve clinical problems. The steps should not be treated as individual components but instead should progress fluidly and in a manner that allows interaction with a requester to be efficiently maintained.

There are several modified systematic approaches to handling information questions that employ evidence-based methods. The exact version used is not as important as the fact that each involves an organised process. Select an approach based on personal preference, professional expectations and what works best for the involved practice setting.

A systematic, seven-step approach

There is a systematic, seven-step approach to respond to medication-related questions or needs. Each step is detailed in the following sections:

Step one: Obtain requester demographics

When responding to an information request, the first step should be to gather general demographic information about the requester. This is important because it allows you to immediately assess the level of understanding of the requester. Most medication-related questions received by pharmacists are from either other healthcare providers or the lay public. Responses to questions should be directly related to the level of understanding of the requester; thus, an answer for a drug interaction question may look markedly different when provided to a healthcare provider than when provided to a patient. Even when the requester is initially categorised as a healthcare provider or lay public, further questioning can be important to assess the requester’s background knowledge and familiarity with the topic. Healthcare professionals — even those practising in the same discipline — can vary greatly in their experiences and training. Assessing the sophistication of the requester allows information to be provided that best meets an individual’s needs.

Other important information to obtain when one receives an information request include:

  • How best to communicate with the requester (e.g. phone number, email address);
  • An assessment of the urgency of the request and the desired delivery method of the response (i.e. verbal or written);
  • The requester’s affiliation or practice site (if a healthcare provider is the requester);
  • When the request was made;
  • The requester’s location (if not at the same site as the clinician who is researching the answer to the request).

Step two: Obtain pertinent background information

Obtaining background information should be part of a seamless transition from gathering the requester’s demographic information to a focus on the question itself. This is often the hardest step for students and clinicians unfamiliar with providing or locating medication or therapy related information on a regular basis. The responder must utilise good communication skills and ask thoughtful, pertinent questions of the requester to characterise fully the precise information need. Identifying the type of background information required and, hence, the type of background-related questions to ask, largely depends on the specific question being asked — or the desired information needed — and the clinical experience of the clinician responder.

Without a broad base of experience, it may be difficult for a clinician to know precisely what background information would be pertinent to a question. In general, clinicians should consider why a certain question has arisen and how the requester is planning to use the response as guidelines to formulate background-related questions to ask. When a clinician receives a request for medication or therapy information, the first question that should always be addressed is whether a specific patient is involved or whether the request is general or academic in nature.

If an information request pertains to a specific patient, the following patient-specific background information might be required to formulate an appropriate response:

  • Age;
  • Gender;
  • Weight;
  • Relevant laboratory data (e.g. to assess renal and hepatic function, appropriateness of any drug levels obtained);
  • Specific medical diagnosis;
  • Relevant past medical history, family and social history;
  • Medications (e.g. current or recent, non-prescription, prescription, natural products);
  • Allergies.

Enquiring about the resources that a requester has already consulted to locate information is another general background question that can be useful to help reduce duplication of efforts. However, it should not be assumed that just because an individual has already checked particular resources, those resources were used effectively. Depending on the requester’s level of information ‘sophistication’, the responder may need to double-check resources already said to be used.

Other background questions that are relevant to an enquiry may be more difficult for the responder to formulate, particularly when the enquiry involves a topic for which the responder has limited familiarity. Fortunately, the ability to refine enquiries by gathering specific, pertinent background information usually improves with practice and experience.

Ultimately, the goal of the background information step is to allow the responder to obtain any additional data needed to answer the question and to determine the ‘real’ question that needs to be addressed. Many initial information requests are clear and represent the actual information need. Other times, however, the initial request does not really state the exact information that is required.

In these situations, it is only through appropriate dialogue and obtaining pertinent background information that the actual need is revealed. For this reason, obtaining background information is paramount for providing a thorough, efficient and appropriate response to address a question.

After all pertinent background information has been obtained, and the actual question and information need have been identified, it is important for the responder to restate the question to the requester. This allows for the appropriate background information to be incorporated into the answer and to ensure that all involved have a clear understanding of the information need and the actual question being asked.

A potential problem when attempting to obtain background information can arise when dealing with a requester who is not the ultimate individual in need of the information. An example of this situation is when a physician asks a pharmacist a question, and the pharmacist in turn contacts a drug information specialist for assistance. Oftentimes this ‘third-party’ or ‘intermediary’ practitioner does not have all of the information needed to answer the specialist’s background-related questions. As a result, the intermediary will have to go back to the original requester for the information needed, or the specialist will need to speak to the original requester directly to obtain the information needed.

Worked example 1: gingival hyperplasia

Suppose a dentist contacts a pharmacist and asks if carvedilol is associated with the development of gingival hyperplasia. The pharmacist in question is busy with other responsibilities but pauses for a moment to look up carvedilol in a tertiary resource that is on hand. The pharmacist does not see gingival hyperplasia listed as an adverse effect for carvedilol and provides this information to the dentist. The dentist accepts the response, and the pharmacist goes back to his duties.

Is there a potential problem here?

While the pharmacist technically provided correct information in response to the question asked, there is no way of knowing if the answer met the dentist’s actual information need owing to the manner in which the pharmacist approached the information request. If the pharmacist had attempted to obtain pertinent background information, the above encounter could have gone much differently.

The following dialogue represents important background questions, with answers provided, that would have helped to clarify the problem appropriately:

Have you looked in any resources to find information for this question?

Answer: I have not used any other resources.

Is this regarding a specific patient?

Answer: Yes.

How long has the patient had the gingival hyperplasia?

Answer: It is unknown exactly. This is the first time the patient has been to my office since his last check-up one year ago when he did not have signs of gingival hyperplasia.

How long has the patient been taking carvedilol?

Answer: Six months.

What other medications is the patient taking?

Answer: Fortamet and Exforge.

How long has the patient been taking those medications?

Answer: Three years for the Fortamet and over a year for the Exforge.

What is the patient’s age?

Answer: 54 years old.

What is the patient’s brushing/flossing habit?

Answer: The patient states he brushes once a day usually, sometimes twice daily. He rarely flosses.

Has the patient ever had this problem in the past?

Answer: No.

The above dialogue was not overly time-consuming, but it did elaborate on the information given in the original question to fully determine the background for the situation and the information needed by the requester. This additional information would have allowed the pharmacist to check all of the patient’s medications for the potential adverse effect of gingival hyperplasia.

Upon review of the other medications, the pharmacist would have discovered that the amlodipine component of Exforge has been linked to gingival hyperplasia and could be the cause of this patient’s condition. This additional information would also have allowed the dentist to address the patient’s problem properly. Thus, the original answer provided by the pharmacist did not address the dentist’s true information need and, more importantly, it did not benefit the patient.

Even when requesters do not volunteer additional information, it is the responder’s responsibility to ask for the additional background information necessary to respond properly. Do not assume that a question does not relate to a specific patient. That assumption often leads to an incomplete response that does not truly fulfil the actual information need, and it may lead to misinformation that could adversely affect patient care.

Step three: Classify the ultimate question

After the actual question or need has been identified from the pertinent background information, it can then be classified. Classifying the question requires a thoughtful determination of its area(s) of focus. A common method of classifying medication and health information questions is by type, such as adverse reaction, therapeutic use, pharmacokinetics, dosing, drug interaction, product identification or availability, etc. Properly classifying the question by type mainly serves as a guide to the appropriate resources to use when researching the question, thus allowing for a more efficient search process.

For example, if the question or information need relates to compounding a formulation, a clinician should focus on using compounding specific resources when researching the answer. Another benefit of classifying questions in this manner is that it allows you to determine the types of questions that arise most often in a practice. This information could be useful when identifying the types of resources to have available in the future.

Step four: Systematic search for information

Similar to obtaining pertinent background information, developing an efficient search strategy is a skill that improves with experience. As stated above, properly classifying the question helps to determine where to begin the search strategy, but each question type or information need might necessitate a completely different search strategy. There are some general guidelines for conducting an appropriate search for information. Most searches begin with the use of tertiary resources. Tertiary resources compile or synthesise information from primary literature, such as published clinical studies, and include textbooks, compendia, electronic databases, such as Micromedex, the British National Formulary, Clinical Pharmacology, and journal review articles. Tertiary resources provide a broad overview of a topic, which could suffice when the information needed is straightforward and fairly well documented. Even if a complete answer is not found in the tertiary resource, it will often explain the involved topic or cite other relevant articles that could help tremendously when continuing the search process.

Consider the following when evaluating the validity of information found in tertiary resources:

  • At least two (if not more) reputable tertiary resources should be consulted. Studies have shown discrepancies and variability in the information contained in commonly used tertiary resources (Vidal L, et al. 2005; Vitry AL. Br J Clin Pharmacol. 2007). Thus, there is no guarantee that information found in any one tertiary resource is accurate or complete;
  • Check the date of publication for print resources or the last update for online resources. There is often a lag time between when information is prepared and when it is published in print. Online tertiary resources might not regularly update all the information contained, regardless of how frequently they ‘update’.

If tertiary resources do not provide a complete answer or if more detailed or current information is needed, secondary resources should be used to locate primary information resources efficiently. It should be noted that secondary resources are also used to find review articles, but, again, these are classified as tertiary literature since they only summarise findings from original research and other sources. However, review articles may further expand upon the information found in other tertiary resources, and they provide citations for primary literature (e.g. original research and studies) that can be accessed for more detailed information. It takes time and practice to become proficient at searching for information.

As a start, clinicians need to become familiar with commonly used and reputable resources. However, it is not enough simply to read about these resources. Clinicians must gain practice in using them to learn the most efficient way to find desired information. Another important aspect of searching for relevant information is taking the time to carefully read the information found. Some clinicians — especially when pressed for time — may skim the information quickly and by doing so may miss important aspects of the information or take aspects of the information out of context from the resource. Both these scenarios can be detrimental in providing an accurate and complete response.

Worked example 2: COPD

A patient is seen in clinic for a follow up of worsening chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) symptoms. The patient had been maintained on an ipratropium inhaler, two puffs four times daily. The patient also takes metoprolol 100mg twice per day for chronic stable angina. The physician would like to start an additional inhaler to improve the patient’s COPD symptoms as the physician insists the metoprolol is not worsening the COPD since it is a B- 1 selective agent and would only affect the heart.

The pharmacist in the clinic quickly looks in a tertiary resource to verify that information. After skimming through the information, they find that metoprolol is a B- 1 selective agent but that it may lose selectivity at higher doses. However, when given this information, the physician states that this is not a high dose of metoprolol and continues with the plan of adding an additional inhaler.

What are the potential problems with the approach taken to find information?

There are several things to consider with this scenario. The pharmacist skimmed through the information quickly to save time, but in doing so gave a less specific answer that metoprolol loses selectivity at higher doses. At what specific dose is selectivity lost for metoprolol? Had the pharmacist read more carefully, the resource used may have provided that specific dose, which would have made their answer more relevant to this specific patient.

Additionally, the pharmacist only used one tertiary resource. As stated previously, it is imperative to use more than one tertiary resource when searching for information. This allows you to verify the information found in one source with others and to identify if any discrepancies exist among the various resources. Even if the clinician had found the specific dose that metoprolol loses selectivity in the first resource used, they need to try and verify that dose in additional resources before finalising the answer.

Step five: Evaluate, analyse and synthesise information found

Finding information in resources is only part of what is needed to answer a question appropriately. It is imperative that clinicians critically evaluate the information retrieved to ensure that it is valid and meets their needs. To critically evaluate information located from the search strategies employed, you must be cognisant of the limitations of each type of resource. To evaluate properly tertiary resources, several questions should be considered:

  • What is the currency of the resource and the information contained? As previously indicated, tertiary resources often have considerable lag times for the inclusion of new information. Even a newly published edition of a tertiary resource may contain out-of-date information;
  • What is the expertise of the authors? Do the authors have sufficient education and experience to discuss the topics covered by the resource appropriately?
  • Does the resource provide reference citations for the information included? Proper reference citations lend credibility to the information provided and allow the clinician to retrieve the articles cited to obtain more detailed information;
  • Was there any obvious bias or were there errors present in the resource? Tertiary references are not free from human error, including incorrect interpretation of information and transcription errors. Authors may also intentionally or unintentionally interject personal bias into their interpretation of studies they review.

The main considerations when evaluating secondary resources primarily involve the appropriate use of the secondary source by the clinician. The following questions should be answered when examining these resources:

  • Was the appropriate secondary resource used?
  • Was any database-specific controlled vocabulary used when conducting the search?
  • Were multiple secondary resources used when conducting the search?
  • How much time does it take for the secondary resource to index new primary literature? If there is a long lag time for new articles to be included, the secondary resource may not contain the most recent information.

Evaluating the primary literature is discussed in detail in a series of Pharmaceutical Journal articles, and those concepts should be applied to this step of the modified systematic approach prior to preparing an appropriate response to an enquiry.

Synthesising a response must take into account a critical evaluation of the information found. Consideration of the limitations of the resources used is paramount to providing a logical, rational response. This is especially true when conflicting information is located. It is unethical to provide an answer that omits relevant information simply because it might not support the recommendation being made. However, clinicians can and should clearly describe the strengths and limitations of any conflicting information to present the conclusion they believe is best supported by the evidence.

The first step in synthesising a response is restating — in writing or verbally, as appropriate — the initial question, including any pertinent background information. By restating the question, one can ensure that all of the required information will be included in the response. Objective, balanced and unbiased information should then be presented in a concise, logical format that allows the recipient to follow and understand the response easily. Finally, any response should end with a brief conclusion and summary of the important aspects of the information presented.

Worked example 3: Ivermectin

A request to provide clinical trial information regarding the use of ivermectin to treat patients with COVID-19 infection is received. The requester would like this information to help inform them of possible treatment decision when caring for patients with COVID-19. Upon questioning, they are interested in trials involving hospitalised patients, as well as outpatients with COVID-19. A proper search for primary literature is conducted, and several trials are found related to both patient populations.

Several of the more recent and larger trials do not show benefit in treating COVID-19 with ivermectin in either inpatients or outpatients, but there are also some smaller earlier trials that did show some benefits with certain COVID-19 outcomes when using ivermectin. You analyse each trial appropriately to assess strengths and limitations. The trials that showed no benefit of using ivermectin generally were more recent, better designed and larger trials when compared to trials that showed benefit of using ivermectin. Based on this, you conclude that ivermectin should probably not be used to treat patients infected with COVID-19.

What information should be included when synthesizing the information found to answer the question?

Although you may have strong personal feelings that ivermectin should not be used to treat patients with COVID-19, it is still important to provide a balanced and unbiased response to this question. Therefore, a description of all the relevant studies — both for and against the use of ivermectin — should be included in the response. This does not mean that you must include every single study found, but you should include a good representation of information found. This also does not mean that you cannot provide a conclusion that ivermectin is not effective for treating COVID-19, if that is what is supported by the preponderance of evidence.

For this question, it would be beneficial to separate the trials evaluating ivermectin for COVID-19 in hospitalised patients versus outpatients with COVID-19. Providing details of trials that show benefit and do not show benefit in each of these patient types would then be reasonable. Include enough detail in the trial descriptions to illustrate potential strengths and limitations of each trial. Finally, providing an unbiased conclusion that reflects the preponderance of evidence should be provided.

Step six: Provide response

Responses to information needs or requests must be provided in a timely manner (i.e. within the time frame initially identified), at a level appropriate for the requester (e.g. healthcare provider versus patient), and in the format agreed upon (i.e. verbal versus written). Good communication skills must also be utilised in this step. The delivery of a verbal response (e.g. confidently providing information, speaking clearly, correct pronunciation and use of medical terminology) greatly affects how the information is received. In addition to the use of appropriate communication skills when presenting information, those same skills are important for maintaining dialogue with the requester after the information is received. Such dialogue allows any other questions or concerns to be appropriately addressed at the time the response is given. In this regard, the clinician responder should have anticipated in advance additional questions that may arise and be prepared to address them as well.

Step 7: Follow up and document

Follow up is important to ensure that a response truly provides what is needed, and it allows any additional needs to be identified. Follow up can be done at the time that the response is provided and, if necessary, at a later time as well. For example, an answer might be formulated that is complete and accurate based on background-related data or other information available at the time. However, suppose that two weeks later, an article is published that provides additional insight into the question originally asked. This new information should also be provided to the requester as an update to the original answer.

Documenting medication and health information questions and responses should be done routinely if such responsibilities are part of a clinician’s practice responsibilities, or when part of patient care provision. The level of documentation can vary, but at a minimum should include contact information for the requester, the question asked or information needed, including relevant background information, the response and the references used in preparing the response.

There can be differences in the legal liability and moral obligations related to the provision of medication and health information. Moreover, ethical considerations should also be included in the process of providing this information. For example, traditionally, physicians are described as the learned intermediary, which means they are ultimately responsible for communicating manufacturer’s warnings to patients. Historically, this has meant pharmacists are not legally responsible for patient harm resulting from a legally prescribed medication when they fail to warn patients of potential harm. However, even if not legally liable, the pharmacist has a moral and ethical responsibility to inform the patient of potential harms that can be caused by medications. Furthermore, with increased patient care roles assumed by pharmacists, the learned intermediary, as it relates to pharmacist liability, may not stand in future court cases.

Legal implications of providing medication and health information may have more to do with negligence, especially when it relates to potential patient harm. Negligence relates to failure to provide an expected level of care that another ‘reasonable’ person would provide given the same circumstances. Thus, a pharmacist who fails to meet established professional conduct that leads to harm can be negligent. Negligent activity related to providing medication and health information that could lead to legal liability could include providing incomplete, inaccurate, low-quality or outdated information, especially when related to failure to exercise reasonable care. Legal liability can also be increased when the pharmacy or pharmacist volunteers or actively promotes information services.

Additionally, providing medication and health information often requires extensive analysis and interpretation of available information sources, which may also increase potential liability. However, by establishing and following a standard, systematic approach when providing medication and health-related information as described in this article, clinicians can greatly reduce their potential liability. Following the guidelines addressed in this module and using the information presented in subsequent modules should minimise the potential for providing incomplete, inaccurate, poor quality and outdated information, as well as increase the ability to accurately and reliably analyse and interpret the available information. Legal liability aside, moral and professional ethics obligate clinicians to provide accurate, timely and complete information when requested.

Key points

  • A systematic approach to answering medication and health information questions or finding needed information is a useful tool to ensure that all important aspects are considered;
  • Obtaining requester demographics and appropriate background information for the question is essential for determining the actual information need;
  • A comprehensive, systematic search strategy should be employed that includes the use of tertiary, secondary and primary resources as appropriate;
  • Properly critiquing information is essential to ensure that it is accurate and relevant to the question or need;
  • A balanced and unbiased analysis of the relevant information should be prepared that includes discussion of any limitations and an appropriate conclusion;
  • The response should be communicated at an appropriate level;
  • Follow up is important to ensure that the response met the needs and to assess whether any additional information is required.

How to apply to practice

Approach each medication-related question or need using a systematic process that includes:

  • Thoughtful consideration of related patient needs;
  • A logical searching process to find relevant information;
  • Critical analysis of the strengths and limitations of the resources used, as well as the information obtained;
  • Logical, thorough answers that discuss any conflicting information found provide a conclusion and summary, and include the references used.

Summary

A systematic approach to responding to medication- and health-related questions is important to ensure that responses are consistent, accurate and thorough, regardless of the involved situation. The steps in this approach should progress fluidly and good communication skills should be maintained throughout the process. This chapter describes one version of a seven-step systematic approach to addressing medication- and health-related questions or related information needs, and it details the important concepts to consider with each step.

Self-assessment questions

Question 1

Responses to information requests by healthcare providers are always likely to take the same form. True or false?

Question 2

The goal of obtaining background information is to ensure the responder to a drug information check addresses the ‘real’ question. True or false?

Question 3

When synthesising a response, you only need to include the evidence that supports your recommendation. True or false?

Question 4

What is a potential concern when using a systematic approach to respond to medication or health-related questions?

Question 5

You are asked the following question by another clinician: ‘What is the risk of taking lisinopril during pregnancy?’ What additional background questions should be asked to clarify this question?

Question 6

A physician has a patient taking insulin. He wants to know what the incidence is of a hypersensitivity reaction to insulin. What additional questions would you ask this physician to clarify the information need further?

Question 7

What are some important considerations with the use of tertiary resources for locating information?

Question 8

Why is it important to present a balanced answer, including any limitations of information found, for a specific question?

Question 9

What are the steps for formulating the response to a medication information question?

Question 10

What is the importance of providing follow up to the question asked?

Question 11

How does obtaining demographic information about the requester change the approach to answering medication and health related questions?

Answer guidance

Question 1

False: Even when the requester is initially categorised as a healthcare provider or lay public, further questioning can be important to assess the requester’s background knowledge and familiarity with the topic. Healthcare professionals — even those practising in the same discipline — can vary greatly in their experiences and training. Assessing the sophistication of the requester allows information to be provided that best meets an individual’s needs.

Question 2

True: Many initial information requests are clear and represent the actual information need. Other times, however, the initial request does not really state the exact information that is required. In these situations, it is only through appropriate dialogue and obtaining pertinent background information that the actual need is revealed. For this reason, obtaining background information is paramount for providing a thorough, efficient and appropriate response to address a question.

Question 3

False: It is unethical to provide an answer that omits relevant information simply because it might not support the recommendation being made. However, clinicians can and should clearly describe the strengths and limitations of any conflicting information to present the conclusion they believe is best supported by the evidence.

Question 4

An important concern with using a systematic approach is ensuring that the process itself does not become fragmented. If each step is approached as an independent task or lacks a logical and concise flow, the process will be choppy and inefficient. While each step in a systematic approach is important, no step should stand alone without consideration of the other involved steps. The steps of any approach should be used as a guide to ensure the response is accurate and thorough, but each step should build on previous ones.

Question 5

The first question asked should determine if a specific patient is involved. If so, additional questions should be asked such as:

  • Is the patient currently pregnant or planning on becoming pregnant?
  • What is the lisinopril being used to treat (e.g. hypertension, proteinuria, heart failure)?
  • What trimester is the patient in and when during the pregnancy did she receive lisinopril?
  • How long did the patient receive lisinopril and at what dose?

All of these questions help to clarify the clinical scenario in the question posed and allow for the provision of specific information to meet the needs of the requester.

Question 6

  • Did this patient experience a hypersensitivity reaction while using insulin?
  • What other medications was the patient taking when the hypersensitivity reaction occurred?
  • What type of insulin is the patient taking?
  • How long has the patient been taking the insulin and any other medications?
  • What dose of insulin and any other medications is the patient taking?
  • What was the temporal relationship with insulin and any other medications to the hypersensitivity reaction?
  • What were the characteristics of the hypersensitivity reaction?
  • Has the patient ever experienced a similar type of reaction previously?

All of these questions can help to refine the clinical scenario in the question posed and might allow the requester to focus the direction of the response better.

Question 7

Limitations to consider when assessing tertiary resources include the currency of the information, the author’s expertise in the subject area, the use and citation of references, and the presence of bias or other errors. Remember that the information found in tertiary resources can be outdated, owing to a possibly long lag time when publishing print resources or owing to inconsistent updating of online resources. The authors should have sufficient experience in the topic presented, and the citation of references lends credibility to the information found in tertiary resources. At least two credible tertiary resources should be used to verify information found.

Question 8

It is an ethical responsibility of the responder to provide both the advantages and disadvantages of recommendations made, as well as the limitations of the information found when providing responses to questions. The information retrieved should be analysed and critiqued through the use of proper evaluation skills. The answer should include the strengths and limitations of the evidence used to prepare recommendations, which will allow the requester to understand fully the rationale behind them.

Question 9

Information requests and needs should be handled using an evidence-based approach. The original question should be restated if needed to include pertinent background information. Appropriate resources should be used to gather relevant information, and the response should detail the information found in a logical and concise manner. The response should address all important aspects of the actual question. Ideas presented should flow in a rational, logical manner that is easily followed and understood. The response should end with a brief conclusion and summary of important points.

Question 10

Follow up allows the responder to assess if the information provided truly met a requester’s needs. It also provides an opportunity to assess if there are additional questions or if any further information is needed. Follow up also involves the provision of new information that might become available after the original response was delivered.

Question 11

Obtaining specific demographic information about the requester allows you to determine their level of knowledge related to the material being requested. This allows you to tailor the response to the question to meet their needs more specifically. If the requester is a fellow clinician, then a more technical response can be formulated as opposed to using lay-language terms when providing information to a patient. However, the overall approach using a systematic system when answering these questions should not change regardless of the knowledge level of the requester.

Acknowledgements

This article was adapted from Drug Information and Literature Evaluation, Second Edition, previously published by Pharmaceutical Press.

A full list of resources and materials used to prepare the book can be accessed from the bibliography page.


  1. 1.
    Watanabe A, Conner C. Principles of Drug Information Services. Drug Intelligence Publications; 1978. https://openlibrary.org/books/OL11411498M/Principles_of_Drug_Information_Services
  2. 2.
    Galt K, Calis K, Turcasso N. Clinical Skills Program: Module 3 Drug Information. American Society of Health-System Pharmacists Inc; 1995. https://www.academia.edu/38919977/Drug_information
Last updated
Citation
The Pharmaceutical Journal, PJ November 2026, Vol 317, No 8015;317(8015)::DOI:10.1211/PJ.2026.1.437820

    Please leave a comment 

    You might also be interested in…